Year(s) of Service, followed by Pastors Names
1837-1838 Rev. Allen John
1838-1839 Rev. Michael D. Kurtz
1839-1840 Rev. Joseph Mann
1840-1842 Rev. James Harmer
1842-1843 Rev. James Flannery
1844-1845 Rev. Peter J. Cox
1846-1847 Rev. John W. Arthur
1848-1849 Rev. John Chew Thomas
1849-1851 Rev. George R. Crooks
1851-1852 Rev. Allen John
1852-1853 Rev. James Hand
1854-1855 Rev. Abram Freed
1856-1857 Rev. John Edwards
1858-1859 Rev. Daniel L. Patterson
1860-1861 Rev. John B. Dennison
1861-1862 Rev. Valentine Gray
1862-1864 Rev. Joseph Aspril
1864-1865 Rev. Samuel G. Hare
1865-1867 Rev. John Allen
1867-1870 Rev. William M. Swindells
1870-1872 Rev. Samuel W. Kurtz
1872-1874 Rev. Michael D. Kurtz
1873-1877 Rev. Noble Frame
1876-1878 Rev. T. Snowden Thomas
1877-1880 Rev. Joseph S. Cook
1879-1883 Rev. George S. Broadbent
1882-1886 Rev. Jacob S. Hughes
1885-1890 Rev. Samuel W. Gehrett, D.D.
1889-1892 Rev. Alpha G. Kynett, D.D.
1891-1895 Rev. William M. Ridgway
1894-1897 Rev. Stephen H. Evans
1896-1898 Rev. William H. Lindemuth, D.D.
1897-1901 Rev. John Stringer
1900-1906 Rev. William Henry Ford
1905-1911 Rev. Benjamin T. Callan
1910-1916 Rev. Wilmer L. Gray
1915-1917 Rev. George Gaul
1916-1920 Rev. Everett D. Decker, D.D.
1919-1922 Rev. D. A. Hinkle
1921-1924 Rev. H. Foster Hamer
1923-1925 Rev. J. Edwin Grawley
1924-1930 Rev. George F. Connor
1929-1935 Rev. J. George Smith
1934-1939 Rev. William H. Lindemuth, D.D.
1939-1944 Rev. Douglass Ingram Cloud
1944-1949 Rev. Horace N. Olewiler
1949-1956 Rev. Martin J. Brinton
1956-1974 Rev. Lewis C. Leaming
1974-1978 Rev. Donald E. Ray
1978-1986 Rev. Robert H. Hoffman
1986-1987 Rev. Harold J. Hallam
1987 (July-October) Rev. William Spiegelhalder (Interim)
1987-1998 Rev. Larry D. Carl
1998-2000 Rev. Nancy Doughtery
2001 Rev. William T. Kreichbaum (Interim)
2001-Present Rev. William Humes
List compiled by Susan M. McDonald, 2007
Associate Pastors:
2003-2008 – James V. Jannotti, Jr.
